10 Best Coffee Creamer Alternatives

There’s nothing better than starting your day with a cup of freshly brewed coffee. You pour it out into your favorite cup, add in your go-to creamer, and for the next 10 minutes, life is great!

But what if you realize you’re out of creamer? Or perhaps you’re trying to improve your diet by cutting down on your sugar consumption. Does that mean you have to give up your morning coffee?

Not at all! Try out these excellent coffee creamer alternatives and continue enjoying your daily cup of Joe.

The Best Coffee Creamer Alternatives 

While coffee creamers are delicious, they do content high amounts of sugar in them. Most coffee creamers also have high fructose corn syrup, artificial sweeteners, carrageenan, and colors.

All of these ingredients can be detrimental to human health. That is why more and more people are now looking for healthier, sugar-free, and low-calorie alternatives to put in their daily cups of coffee.

If you’ve been searching for healthy coffee creamers to try out, you’re at the right place. Here are some of the best ingredients to try out with your coffee this morning.

You won’t even notice the missing coffee creamer with them!

Traditional Milk / Cream

The first coffee creamer alternative is perhaps the most obvious one – milk or cream!

Did you know that people simply used milk in their coffees before coffee creamer started being stocked in the grocery stores? You can simply go back to this older practice for healthier coffee!

The best part about this is that you can use different types of milk and cream in your coffee. Try out the following kinds and see which resonates the most with your taste buds.

Whole Cow Milk

Whole cow milk is perhaps one of the most popular choices when it comes to coffee creamer alternatives.

It is less fatty than cream but still has enough fat content to make a delicious cup of brew. Adding whole cow milk to your coffee makes it taste smoother and silkier.

However, you should keep in mind that this isn’t the best choice for people who are lactose intolerant.

If your body is unable to digest lactose, you should consider opting for lactose-free milk. You can also use different plant-based milk varieties as creamers for your coffee.

Goat Milk

Goat milk is recently gaining popularity, and people think it could even replace cow’s milk as the most enjoyed kind of milk.

This milk has earthy flavor notes with a sweet yet slightly sour taste. This flavor profile makes it a great choice to pair with your bitter coffee.

The best part is that goat milk is easier for the stomach to digest than cow’s milk. So people who experience upset stomachs after having cow’s milk can easily enjoy it as their coffee creamer.

2% or Skimmed Milk

If you’re on a low-fat diet or simply trying to reduce the number of calories you consume, this is the right choice for you.

2% or skimmed milk has a significantly lowered fat content as compared to whole milk. This also makes it a healthier choice when it comes to coffee creamer alternatives.

However, you should keep in mind that the reduced fat content will change the texture of your coffee. It won’t have the same silky smooth taste as coffee made with creamer or whole milk.

Whipping Cream

Whipping cream is another popular, albeit not too healthy, choice for coffee creamer alternatives.

It is a decadent treat that makes absolutely delicious coffee. With this dairy goodness, you will get a cup of coffee that is smooth and creamy.

Simply add a dollop or two of whipping cream into your cup of coffee. Stir it well, and enjoy your cup!

Condensed Milk

Most people don’t consider condensed milk as a type of milk, but it’s right there in its name!

Condensed milk is another canned treat that you can use as a coffee creamer alternative. It has zero water content, so you end up with a thicker, creamer cup of coffee.

You can choose between sweetened and unsweetened condensed milk for your morning drink.

While the unsweetened version is the healthier choice, the sweetened kind gives you a taste that is closer to your usual creamer.

If you aren’t too fond of using canned products, you can also make condensed milk at home! Simply use an online recipe, and you’re good to go.


Butter coffee recently became a unique online trend that everyone was eager to try! The fact, however, is that people have been enjoying butter coffee for years.

Also known as keto coffee, butter coffee is simply your ordinary cup of coffee with butter used as a replacement for your usual creamer.

Since butter is made of milk and has high fat content, it makes a perfectly silky cup of coffee. The best part is that adding butter to coffee also has numerous health benefits.

Butter coffee is known to leave you feeling fuller for longer, reducing the chances of binge eating and snacking on junk food. It also boosts your metabolism and helps you burn fat.

Cocoa Butter

Next up, we have a coffee creamer alternative for people who don’t quite like the idea of plain old butter in their coffee.

You can add a teaspoon of cocoa butter to your coffee instead! It eliminates the need to use creamer and gives you a deliciously smooth coffee.

The best part is that cocoa butter adds subtle notes of chocolate to your coffee, making it even more delicious.

Cocoa butter is also a keto-friendly coffee creamer alternative. It offers you the benefits of high antioxidant content while also being dairy-free.

Apple Cider Vinegar

Seeing apple cider vinegar on this list might come off as a surprise, but trust us, it works!

Simply heat up a tablespoon of apple cider vinegar and add it to your cup of coffee. Add half a teaspoon of apple pie seasoning and your coffee will taste better than ever!

Since apple cider vinegar is packed with healthy nutrients, it makes the perfect alternative to coffee creamers. You get a daily dose of vitamins and minerals.

Vinegar also helps in lowering blood sugar levels and assists in losing weight.

Coconut Milk

Canned coconut milk is known to be the perfect base to make your own coffee creamer. This is because it has a thick consistency and richness of a typical store-bought creamer.

You can either add coconut milk directly to your coffee or make a delicious vanilla coconut milk creamer at home.

Just add a can of coconut milk into a glass bottle and add 2 teaspoons of vanilla extract to it. Close the bottle tight and shake it for 30 – 40 seconds. That’s it!

You can add a dash of maple syrup to your creamer for an even better taste.

Sweetened Cashew Milk

Are you looking for a way to enjoy sweetened coffee creamer without the excessive sugar content?

You can simply make your own sweetened creamer with cashew milk and a natural sweetener. An excellent natural sweetener you use is dates. It is healthier and has lesser calories too!

You can either use store-bought cashew milk to make your creamer or blend it up at home.

Simply add your cashew milk, some filtered water, a few pitted dates, some cocoa powder, and ground cinnamon to a blender. Mix it up well and add a dash of kosher salt.

Your all-natural, sweetened coffee creamer is ready to be enjoyed!

Egg Yolks

While adding raw egg yolks to your coffee might sound a little gross, it is actually quite a popular trick!

Koreans have been adding egg yolks to their coffee since the 1940s. The country faced a shortage of milk, and people started using yolks instead. Turns out egg yolks actually make delicious creamers.

If you’re worried about getting salmonella, you can simply get some pasteurized yolks from the grocery store. All you need to do is whisk egg yolk and stir it into your coffee.

Not only does it taste delicious, but the yolk also adds folic acid, antioxidants, and essential vitamins to your drink.

Plant-Based Milk

Lastly, there is a variety of different plant-based milk types that you can add to your coffee as a substitute for creamers.

Since many people can’t digest dairy too well once they get older, these milk types are great choices for them. They are healthy, vegan, low-fat options to add to your coffee for a delicious cup of brew.

Almond Milk

Almond milk is the most popular lactose-free type of milk for people who are lactose intolerant. It sweetens your coffee slightly to balance the bitter taste and gives it a delicious nutty taste.

Soy Milk

Soy milk is another excellent non-dairy alternative to coffee creamers. It only adds a slight touch of sweetness to your coffee, making it a good choice for people who enjoy the bitter taste.

Oat Milk

The final coffee creamer alternative is oat milk. It is also lactose-free and has the lowest fat content. This makes it an ideal choice for people on low-fat diets.

However, the reduced fat content does make your coffee less silky when you use oat milk as your creamer.

We hope you enjoy your coffee with these creamer alternatives!

Other articles you may also like: